Sunday, April 4, 2010

Living in a Measurement World-Giving an A

2 comments:

jbb said...

Lots of great observations. On the surface it would seem that Zander's process is more fitting for more mature students. But I think that there is no better age to give a student the reins of their own learning than when they are young. But just like sticking a giant steak in front of a toddler, one will have so much more success if one cuts the whole into much smaller bite sized pieces. So, instead of having them sign off on a whole year or semester, that they are going to do this or that and that's why they got an A, maybe one can say what am I going to do this week or today and that why I got (future tense) an A.

musicmann8855 said...

I enjoy your reflective prospective on this chapter. We have some very common views on these subjects. I really liked the giving an A chapter as a teaching philosophy. I wrote about how we should strive to give each student an A.

As a student, though in this program, I was frustrated by the number of Absolute A projects in our classes. I was, as you mentioned, thinking of the lazy person and how they were getting the same grade as me even if they did not try. In the book, I liked the idea because the class was about expression, and how can you really grade expression. So I guess my big question is how to you hold someone accountable in an Absolute A assignment?

I also have the video on 21st Century learners posted on my blog; I feel it has so much to do with these chapters.